People · Judges
Cármen Lúcia Antunes Rocha
Justice of the STF; changed her vote and formed the majority for Moro's bias ruling in the Second Panel on March 23, 2021, and was rapporteur of Dallagnol's appeal against the compensation to Lula.
Being in this archive does not mean having committed any wrongdoing. Procedural status: see each case and episode, with date.
According to the STF, the Second Panel recognized by majority, in HC 164.493, Moro's partiality in Lula's conviction in the triplex case; Ricardo Lewandowski and Cármen Lúcia (who adjusted her vote) followed Gilmar Mendes's dissent, while Edson Fachin (rapporteur) and Nunes Marques voted against.
Source: 2ª Turma reconhece parcialidade de ex-juiz Sérgio Moro na condenação de Lula no caso Triplex — Supreme Federal Court, Mar. 23, 2021 · body of the news item · open original ↗
Eu disse que estava aberta a novos elementos e o julgamento não acabou. Está tendo sequência o julgamento e com dados desse momento é que profiro o voto
Portal translation: I said I was open to new elements and the trial was not over. The trial is continuing and it is with the data of this moment that I cast my vote
Cármen Lúcia · March 23, 2021 · Vote · Second Panel of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (HC 164.493)
Context, original and sources →Todo mundo tem direito a um julgamento justo, por um juiz imparcial
Portal translation: Everyone has the right to a fair trial, before an impartial judge
Cármen Lúcia · March 23, 2021 · Vote · Second Panel of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (HC 164.493)
Context, original and sources →Lula's defense argued that Moro's acceptance of Jair Bolsonaro's invitation to the Ministry of Justice would indicate bias and political motivation; Cármen Lúcia cited the forced appearance for questioning without prior summons and the interception of lawyers and said her vote did not consider conversations released by the press and absent from the case file.
Source: 2ª Turma reconhece parcialidade de ex-juiz Sérgio Moro na condenação de Lula no caso Triplex — Supreme Federal Court, Mar. 23, 2021 · section on arguments · open original ↗
On May 24, 2023, Justice Cármen Lúcia found inadmissible the habeas corpus filed by a third party, in the records of RE 1.433.814, to annul decisions in the compensation lawsuit, without examining the merits of the extraordinary appeal.
Source: Por questões processuais, STF rejeita pedido de terceiro que questionava condenação de Deltan Dallagnol por entrevista com powerpoint — Supreme Federal Court, May 24, 2023 · body of the news item · open original ↗
On April 22, 2024, Cármen Lúcia rejected the appeal by Dallagnol and the ANPR against the STJ decision, stating that any violation of the Constitution would be indirect and that the STJ had already resolved the infraconstitutional questions.
Source: STF mantém decisão que obriga Deltan a indenizar Lula por PowerPoint — CNN Brasil, Apr. 22, 2024 · body of the article · open original ↗
On June 11, 2024, the STF First Panel, in a virtual session and unanimously (Cristiano Zanin recused), upheld the decision of rapporteur Cármen Lúcia, joined by Flávio Dino, Alexandre de Moraes and Luiz Fux; the rapporteur said the arguments showed 'only nonconformity and resistance'.
Source: STF mantém decisão que obriga Dallagnol a pagar indenização a Lula — Poder360, June 11, 2024 · body of the article · open original ↗
In the Plenary, Gilmar Mendes, Nunes Marques, Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli and Ricardo Lewandowski and Justices Rosa Weber and Cármen Lúcia voted for the thesis that only the Internal Rules authorize the Plenary to review panel decisions; Edson Fachin, Luís Roberto Barroso, Marco Aurélio and Luiz Fux dissented.
Source: STF confirma suspeição de Sergio Moro na ação do triplex do Guarujá — Supreme Federal Court (Communications Secretariat), June 23, 2021 · "Regimento" (Internal Rules) section · open original ↗
According to Poder360, in 2018, when HC 164.493 began to be judged, Justice Cármen Lúcia voted against Moro's bias ruling, following rapporteur Edson Fachin.
Source: Cármen Lúcia muda voto e STF declara Moro parcial em condenação de Lula — Poder360, Mar. 23, 2021 · Fifth paragraph · open original ↗
