Skip to content
LAVAJATO.ORGrecovered × cost

Statement library · Debate

Luís Roberto Barroso, April 22, 2021

“Pensei que fosse vossa excelência fosse garantista. Essa é uma prova ilícita. É produto de crime. Então o crime compensa para vossa excelência?”

Portal translation: I thought Your Excellency was a garantista. This is illicit evidence. It is the product of a crime. So does crime pay for Your Excellency?

The translation is the portal's; the original text, in Portuguese, is the one that prevails.

Context
In a debate with Ricardo Lewandowski, Barroso questioned the use of messages obtained by hacking phones.
Where
Debate · Full court (Plenary) of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (session on Moro's bias)
Verification
Checked against the journalistic record: Julgamento de suspeição tem embate sobre "legado lavajatista", on Oct. 24, 2026. Quotation from ConJur; the repetition "whether your excellency is or is not" is in the original.
Topics
bias ruling, stf, vaza jato
Mentions
Ricardo Lewandowski

Related events

Sources

Julgamento de suspeição tem embate sobre "legado lavajatista" — Consultor Jurídico, Apr. 22, 2021 · original ↗

Related statements

Entender-se de forma diversa, que resultado de tais crimes seriam utilizáveis, seria uma forma transversa de legalizar a atividade hacker no Brasil

Portal translation: To understand it otherwise, that the results of such crimes would be usable, would be an indirect way of legalizing hacking activity in Brazil

Nunes Marques · March 23, 2021 · Vote · Second Panel of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (HC 164.493)

Context, original and sources →
o saldo é extremamente positivo

Portal translation: the balance is extremely positive

Luís Roberto Barroso · April 22, 2021 · Debate · Full court (Plenary) of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (session on Moro's bias)

Context, original and sources →
O modus operandi da 'lava jato' levou a conduções coercitivas, prisões preventivas alongadas, prisões em segunda instância e outras atitudes incompatíveis com o Estado democrático de Direito

Portal translation: The modus operandi of 'lava jato' led to coercive conduction orders, prolonged pretrial detentions, arrests after second-instance rulings and other actions incompatible with the democratic rule of law

Ricardo Lewandowski · April 22, 2021 · Debate · Full court (Plenary) of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (session on Moro's bias)

Context, original and sources →

All statements by Luís Roberto Barroso · Identifier: fala:barroso-2021-04-22-prova-ilicita