Skip to content
LAVAJATO.ORGrecovered × cost

Statement library · Vote

Nunes Marques, March 23, 2021

“Entender-se de forma diversa, que resultado de tais crimes seriam utilizáveis, seria uma forma transversa de legalizar a atividade hacker no Brasil”

Portal translation: To understand it otherwise, that the results of such crimes would be usable, would be an indirect way of legalizing hacking activity in Brazil

The translation is the portal's; the original text, in Portuguese, is the one that prevails.

Context
Nunes Marques voted against the bias ruling on Moro and spoke on the use of the Vaza Jato dialogues as evidence.
Where
Vote · Second Panel of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (HC 164.493)
Verification
Checked against the journalistic record: Cármen Lúcia muda voto e STF declara Moro parcial em condenação de Lula, on Oct. 24, 2026. Quotation from Poder360; video not watched. Dissenting position included for balance.
Original
www.youtube.com/watch?v=SoYCNLTH4vQ
Topics
bias ruling, stf, vaza jato

Comparisons

Related events

Sources

Cármen Lúcia muda voto e STF declara Moro parcial em condenação de Lula — Poder360, Mar. 23, 2021 · original ↗

Related statements

Essa prova foi obtida por meio ilícito e violou a Constituição Federal

Portal translation: This evidence was obtained by illicit means and violated the Federal Constitution

Luiz Fux · June 23, 2021 · Sentence · Supreme Federal Court (STF) — full court (Plenary) (second appeal in HC 193.726 / HC 164.493)

Context, original and sources →
Eu disse que estava aberta a novos elementos e o julgamento não acabou. Está tendo sequência o julgamento e com dados desse momento é que profiro o voto

Portal translation: I said I was open to new elements and the trial was not over. The trial is continuing and it is with the data of this moment that I cast my vote

Cármen Lúcia · March 23, 2021 · Vote · Second Panel of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (HC 164.493)

Context, original and sources →
O Tribunal de Curitiba é conhecido mundialmente como um tribunal de exceção. Enche-nos de vergonha

Portal translation: The Curitiba Court is known worldwide as a court of exception. It fills us with shame

Gilmar Mendes · March 23, 2021 · Vote · Second Panel of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (HC 164.493)

Context, original and sources →
Pensei que fosse vossa excelência fosse garantista. Essa é uma prova ilícita. É produto de crime. Então o crime compensa para vossa excelência?

Portal translation: I thought Your Excellency was a garantista. This is illicit evidence. It is the product of a crime. So does crime pay for Your Excellency?

Luís Roberto Barroso · April 22, 2021 · Debate · Full court (Plenary) of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) (session on Moro's bias)

Context, original and sources →

All statements by Nunes Marques · Identifier: fala:nunes-marques-2021-03-23-prova-ilicita